Insideman’s Pull List™ – The Best and Worst Hardcovers, Graphic Novels and Manga for 8.15.12!

Born and raised on newsprint comics, where even the smallest job was “hand done”– I am constantly amazed where inspired artists can take this medium in the digital age. And I’m not talking about sought-after pencilers like David Finch, J.H. Williams III or John Romita Jr… Or their equally adept inkers or colorists.

BIFFBAMBOOM Font from – inspired by the lettering of Artie Simek and Sam Rosen

I’m talking about the letterers, who nowadays do 99% of their work on impersonal computers. Comics Silver Age is where these particular artists really started to excel (and finally began receiving the recognition they deserved).

Marvel’s Artie Simek was the first letterer I remember really appreciating. Then later, John Costanza— primarily for his massive amount of excellent DC Comics work. (Oh, how well Costanza’s lettering meshed with Jim Aparo’s beautiful artwork– particularly on a Batman comic!) After that, I couldn’t help but notice the style and innovation of the equally prolific Todd Klein. There were other greats, of course, and, especially in the earlier years– a lot of bad letterers too.

As a kid, knowing who lettered a book meant a lot to me– but I had no idea it had developed into a minor obsession as I grew older. How much great comic book lettering affected me was never more clear than when a colleague introduced me to John Costanza in the halls of DC Comics one day. I immediately launched into this 20 minute (I’m not kidding) praise-filled recollection about how much I loved and admired his lettering and how much it meant to me when I saw his name listed in a comic book’s credits. I later discovered this kid’s enthusiasm spooked John a little. (Thankfully, I was able to prove to him later I wasn’t quite as “bug nuts crazy” as I seemed that day.)

In other news, it’s a shit week this week. (Remember, there are FIVE Wednesdays this month). Not saying there aren’t a few books with great buzz but many I have already touted in previous columns (Betrayal of the Planet of the Apes, B.P.R.D, etc)… Otherwise, nothing really stands out– especially when I made the decision to overlook any potential POS* with Rob Liefeld’s name attached to it.

Batman Streets Of Gotham Vol 3 House Of Hush – Own the Hardcover
Betrayal of the Planet of the Apes
B.P.R.D. Volume 17 Hell On Earth Volume 3 Russia
Cable Classic Vol 3
Captain America By Ed Brubaker Vol 1 – Own the Hardcover
Captain Easy Vol 3 Soldier Of Fortune HC
Complete Peanuts Box Set 1983-1986
Complete Peanuts Vol 18 1985-1986 HC
Conan The Daughters Of Midora And Other Stories
Creativity Of Steve Ditko HC
Darkness Compendium Vol 2 Limited S&N HC
Definitive Flash Gordon and Jungle Jim Vol 2 HC
Elektra Assassin (New Print)
Empowered Deluxe Edition Volume 2 HC – Own the Trade Volumes
Essential Warlock Vol 1
Four Horsemen Of The Apocalypse Vol 2
GI Joe Disavowed Vol 6
Golden Twine
Green Lantern Green Arrow – The O’Neil/Adams classics…
Hawk And Dove Vol 1 First Strikes – The flip-side to the book listed above…
Hulk Season One HC
Infestation 2 Vol 3
Kill Audio – Recommended. Own the Hardcover
Little Prince Vol 1 Planet Of The Wind
Making Of HC
Mega Man Vol 2 Time Keeps On Slipping
Operation Broken Wings 1936
Red Diary Re(a)d Diary Flipbook HC – I’m probably most looking forward to this…
Star Wars The Clone Wars The Sith Hunters
Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles Classics Vol 1
Treasury 20th Century Murder Vol 5 Lovers Lane HC
Ultimate Comics Spider-Man By Brian Bendis Vol 1 – Own the Hardcover
Uncanny X-Force Vol 4 Dark Angel Saga Book 2 – Own the Hardcover

Air Gear Vol 25
Bamboo Blade Vol 14
Betrayal Knows My Name Vol 4
Bunny Drop Vol 6
Cage of Eden Vol 6
Fairy Tail Vol 12 (Kodansha Edition) – Own the Del Rey Edition
Inu Yasha Vol 12 (Viz BIG Edition)
Itsuwaribito Vol 6
Kekkaishi Vol 33 – Buying the Omnibus Editions
Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya Vol 13
Nabari No Ou Vol 11
Omamori Himari Vol 8
Puella Magi Madoka Magica Vol 2
Soul Eater Vol 10
Voltron Force Vol 3 Twin Trouble

To be a current Ghost Rider fan is exactly the same as being a glutton for punishment. It seems that no matter how much fans love the character or what “name” creators Marvel slops onto the concept– you’ll spend your money for naught… Unless you think the cool fire effects colorists can conjure up via computers these days somehow trumps a forest of wooden characterization and flaccid storytelling.

Unfortunately, having just read Ghost Rider: The Complete Series by Rob Williams– I can report the Ghost Rider dry spell continues sorrowfully unabated.

I’m really not going to go into any grand detail here– other than to say lots of macho action, hellfire and a few testosterone-laced tag lines do not a Ghost Rider comic make. Sadly, it seems the Ghost Rider’s significance as a premiere member of Marvel’s Horror Squad becomes more diluted with each new iteration.

Today I’m looking squarely at Rob Williams new Ghost Rider– who also happens to be a very pretty woman (when she has skin) named Alejandra. Truth be told, her character is so sketchily constructed in this series (as if pausing for any true humanizing character development would be verboten in a Ghost Rider comic), I could really care less about her too.

No, I’m focusing on the fact that when Marvel “okayed” this new female Ghost Rider… Somebody, somewhere decided to give this fire-breathing vengeance seeker big, bountiful breasts… Even when she is in full flaming skeletal mode.

Trust what I type in the next sentence: I am the last person to ever complain about female breasts– in any medium.

But breasts on a Ghost Rider… A burning skeleton? It’s a cheap, stupid stunt that completely grounds this entire enterprise in the first fiery panel she appears in. Marvel, all you have to do is go back and actually read the original origin story to “get” what keeps attracting people to the Ghost Rider– no matter what crap you throw at us.

This character could be so much more than a flaming head in a leather biker outfit. The minute you understand that– and quit doing silly shit like drawing tits on a skeleton– maybe we’ll get somewhere.

This entry was posted in Commentary, COSTLY COMIC BOOKS, Geek Culture, Hardcover Reviews, Hardcovers & Graphic Novels, Hardcovers & Trade Paperbacks, IMJ Nation™, Insideman's Pull List™, Insideman's Weekly Hardcover & Graphic Novel Picks, New This Week, Opinion and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

16 Responses to Insideman’s Pull List™ – The Best and Worst Hardcovers, Graphic Novels and Manga for 8.15.12!

  1. kurumais says:

    i dont know inside in that picture she looks like she is pushing a B with a pushup bra, nothing bountiful about them , but i get your point

  2. Locusmortis says:

    Rob Williams does some pretty good stuff for 2000AD, I guess it must be the curse of Marvel (see Andy Diggle also)

    Your fascination for Letterers sounds like my one for bass guitarists, the unsung heroes of music

    My list of favourite inkers comes mainly from the 80’s generation I guess, Tom Orzechowski, John Workman, Ken Bruzenak and Tom Frame from 2000AD.

    • Insideman says:

      LM, I don’t judge anybody’s work on just what they do for Marvel now. It’s weird– half the books seems OVER-edited to the point of creative strangulation and the other half read like they have NO EDITORS at all.

      To be fair, I am in the middle of reading all that New Krypton mess from DC. I just finished the Mon El Hardcover and it was just horrible. Needless repetition. People learning something in one issue and then acting like they never heard the information in the next. I know James Robinson is entertaining some people with the new Earth 2 comic… But I think he turned hack long before he “came back” to comics.

      Also, I didn’t even bother to mention in the Ghost Rider review that this whole series had a direct (if sometimes tangential) relationship to that Fear Itself mess… That alone helped unnecessarily muddy the waters and make it DOA.

      • Locusmortis says:

        Oh, I stuck through all that New Krypton guff and the War of the Supermen and all that, I ended up giving all those comics to the local charity shop, hopefully they’ll make a few quid off them. New Krypton and the Nightwing/Flamebird team were good ideas, its just the execution was absolutely horrible.

        I agree about Robinson hacking all this stuff out, the Justice League comic coming out about the same time was absolutely horrible as well.

        • Insideman says:

          Jesus H– some of these books Superman New Krypton books are hysterically nonsensical.

          1st, why Nightwing and Flamebird? Nobody could come up with better UNUSED names? I agree there was lots of promise here– completely squandered.

          I’ve counted at least 10 instances where Flamebird’s manifested powers look EXACTLY like Marvel’s Jean Grey/Phoenix.

          I should say I am just getting to the end of it now (about 4 books to go) and the only ones I am enjoying are (no surprise) the stories written by Greg Rucka. I can also see a ton of manipulation by DC Editorial here and while I have no idea if this is true… I can’t help but think it was all the fucking around with this (essentially) interesting story that FIRST led Rucka to become disgusted with mainstream company shenanigans.

          The main plot– Superman living on New Krypton… And the dynamic between Kal El and General Zod was really becoming interesting… And then, just as it gets REALLY intriguing, they have some dope shoot Zod… Taking him out of the narrative.

          Like I said, I haven’t finished them all– so I don’t know what happens next… But I am really pissed they didn’t explore the Supes/Zod dynamic more before they took Zod out.

          I would say about 30 percent of this story has been well executed with 70% varying degrees of trash. And you’re right… It could have been SO much more.

          Oh wait. Why do I care? None of this counts anymore anyway, right? Is there even a Zod in the New 52?

  3. TheMSpot says:

    I can’t believe you read the entire series I didn’t get past the first two issues when I reviewed them way back when. I don’t want to use this phrase, but it felt very “90’s.” Even though, Marvel could have easily relaunched the title with Danny Ketch following the events of Aaron’s run with Danny being jaded by both sides (Heaven and Hell), and taken him on some sort of journey with the new Caretaker (WTF happened to her?!?). Or in the mighty Marvel way, rip off Supernatual and model a series where Blaze and Ketch go on missadventures much like the Winchester brothers. Anyway, I doubt we’ll see a Ghost Rider series of any caliber anytime soon especially after the Gary Friedrich lawsuit.

    Did Alejandra fair any better in Venom: Circle of Four? Or was that a flaming piece of shit as well?

    • Insideman says:

      MSpot, I am not normally lucky in the “timing” department– although I did miss out on about 7.5 years of 90s comics back in the day… And Jose said if there ever was a time to ignore comics… THAT was it.

      Still, I have purchased and read several 90s mainstream/superhero trades and hardcovers since then and, almost overwhelmingly, I thought they stunk. Badly. I can count the number of 90s books I think worth even mentioning on two hands. Haven’t read them all, course. So I might have still missed a few good ones.

      But yes, the Ghost Rider tome was a total slog… And read very much like a 90s comic. All action and little if any coherency and character development. I actually stuck around to see just how bad it would get.

      I also read this Geoff Johns Joe Casey Superman book the other day. What a POS!

      Here’s how emails between Jose and I go every Tuesday as I prepare to make my comic order:


      Does “X-Men XXXX” stink? It looks like more 90s shit. Is it?

      How about this “Wolverine XXXX” hardcover? Same thing?



      J replies:

      Yes and Yes.

      And miraculously– I save $70 bucks! 🙂

  4. Morlock50 says:

    From now on, I will end every sentence with the phase “drawing tits on a skeleton”. Thank you Ian.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s